Top Ten Reasons to Be a Catholic

About this article

In this October 1997 article from St. Anthony Messenger, Kathy Coffey gives nine of her favorite reasons for why she remains Catholic amid church politics, challenges, and struggles. Written with honesty and enthusiasm, the reasons range from Catholicism being a tradition that is universal in nature and remembers Jesus, to being a church that has a rich spirituality and always has something to celebrate. Coffey invites the reader to add the tenth reason based on personal experience!

Many of us have been raised in the Church, but why do we remain Catholic? This author shares her favorite reasons and invites you to consider your own.


When Jesus first asked his disciples this question, it was poignant. Its original context made it heartbreaking. He had recently told the people, “I am the bread of life” (John 6:35). He had offered himself as balm for their deepest longings, promising, “whoever comes to me will never hunger, and whoever believes in me will never thirst” (John 6:35). How did they receive the shining promise, that generous outpouring of his life? John’s Gospel is full of words like quarreling and murmuring, and “they could not accept it.”

Before we are quick to condemn those who turned away, we must ask ourselves the same question: “What about you, do you want to go away too?”

I’d be the first to admit I’ve been tempted. At times, Church politics gets depressing; at other times, the institution seems terminally ill. When some of our thinkers and writers are silenced, I grow sad. Some of my friends have left. So I asked myself, “Why do you stay?” I found it a challenge—as we all might—to articulate beliefs so long and so deeply held that they had become almost dormant.

I’ve borrowed an organizing device from David Letterman’s “Top Ten,” but I’m going to cheat. I’ll give only nine reasons. Then it’s the reader’s turn. If I don’t include your favorite reason, number 10 is up to you.

1. We are the community that remembers Jesus.

I see this especially in the surrendered lives of those who show us Christ’s face, his hands and eyes and words and compassionate touch. We call it the Mystical Body, but it means that we recognize Jesus in the laughter and voices of those around us: little kids, retired folks, teenagers, all those in whom Christ continues to take flesh.

While all Christian communities remember Jesus, Catholics do so in a particular, liturgical way. When someone we love has died and we try to recapture memories of that person, we usually do so through our senses. We remember Grandma’s tortillas, or the song that Grandpa sang off-key. One of my friends whose husband died broke down when she smelled his after-shave lingering in his shirts.

It is the same with Jesus. When we remember him, we grope for the touch of his hands on a loaf of bread, the sound of his voice telling stories, the words he breathed into wine. We find him still in the simplest human activities, eating and drinking, gathering with friends and telling stories.

When I was teaching undergraduates at Regis Jesuit University in Denver, three students asked, “Mrs. Coffey, are you coming to our Mass for Holy Thursday?” I was slightly taken aback. It’s not often that 19-year-old boys invite me to Mass with major enthusiasm. They did not get this excited about the English class I was teaching. So I went. And what I saw is not unique; similar liturgies occur around the country.

My college students were so dressed up I could barely recognize them. They had vested for the high holy days. They carried beautiful banners; they processed reverently with bells and baskets and bread and wine. All the while they chanted Tom Conry’s song, “All people here who remember Jesus, brother and friend. All who hold to his mem’ry, all who keep faith in the end.” It’s for moments like those that I keep returning.


2. Catholicism has universality.

We Irish have our gifts, but mariachi music isn’t one of them. So I’ve been grateful to the people with Spanish and African-American backgrounds for the richness, the color, the vibrancy they bring to our faith. No one tradition has the resources to meet the challenges of the next century. Yet in the Church, we find the pluralism that the human race will need to survive.

Some examples may clarify number two. In Santa Fe, I once attended a workshop that concluded around 10 p.m. It had been a wonderful day, but we were all tired. So when we heard that we’d end with the blessing, the Anglos assumed with typical efficiency, “one size fits all”—one blessing for all of us. Wrong. Every single person got an individual blessing. I learned that night that there are some things so important they don’t fit on a tight schedule.

What universality means, in practical terms, is that on Wednesday night I can visit a poor parish where the people come through pouring rain to sit on folding chairs in a gym with a leaky roof. Then on Saturday, I can fly to a mega-church which cost millions, a parish with the highest concentration of M.D.’s and Ph.D.’s in the country. In both places, we explore the same, unchanging Sunday Gospel that cuts cleanly across all the differences.

At the annual Los Angeles Religious Education Congress, the range of liturgies makes this principle visible. Twenty thousand people fill the Anaheim arena, all glad to be Catholic, all holding hands for the Our Father. Universality takes on flesh when African Americans dance “The Deer’s Cry,” an eighth-century Irish prayer.


3. Catholics make bold claims.

Sometimes these startle people of other traditions. “Who do you think you are?” they might ask. We answer, seriously and repeatedly, we are Christ’s presence on earth today. We cooperate with God to build God’s kingdom in this world. In the Eucharist, we say that through bread and wine, we become the body of Christ. It may sound arrogant, but this is what Jesus meant when he said, “You will do greater things than I have done.” How’s that for a bold claim?

Each sacrament is similar, but take Confirmation as another example. We say, through this ritual gesture of imposing hands and this chrism signed on the forehead, the Spirit comes. The same Spirit transformed terrified disciples who’d locked themselves in a room in fear of the authorities. The same Spirit transfigured the known world through the efforts of 12 people who weren’t especially bright or powerful. This same Spirit is ours.


4. The Church is a family.

The Church is at its best when its members are like family: When we lose sight of that, we become legalistic, antiseptic and cold. Sometimes it’s a dysfunctional family, but it gives my children something broader and deeper than anything I could ever give them alone. My oldest son, David, recently returned from Chicago, where he attended Mass at O’Hare Airport. He said something I’ve waited 23 years to hear: “That’s what I love about being Catholic. It’s the same everywhere in the world. I know what to do when they take up the collection!“

When the rite of election was celebrated at the cathedral in San Antonio, Texas, one little girl could barely reach the Book of the Elect on the altar. So the bishop held her up. She tried to copy her name off her name tag, and got the first name fine. But when the last name proved too much, the bishop wrote it for her—what any kind grandfather would do!

I recently saw a Baptism in Raleigh, North Carolina, that symbolized what we’re all about. A tiny baby was immersed in a huge pool of warm water, then wrapped up in a white towel. The priest brought her forward and called all the children of the parish to meet the new member of the family. While the people said the Creed, the children (hundreds of them, materializing out of the woodwork) marked the Sign of the Cross on the infant. That is typically Catholic: Our most important messages aren’t put in words, but in gestures that speak at a level far deeper than language.


5. We have splendid heroes and heroines.

In a presidential campaign, the Republicans associate themselves with Lincoln, and the Democrats reminded us that they are the party of Kennedy. We could borrow that tactic, saying stoutly, “We are the Church of Catherine of Siena, Francis of Assisi, Ignatius Loyola, Thomas More, Teresa of Avila, Vincent de Paul, Elizabeth Ann Seton, Thomas Merton, Dorothy Day, Oscar Romero, Rigoberta Menchu, the martyrs of El Salvador...”—and the litany could continue.

Richard Rohr, O.F.M., maintains that one difference between a sacred culture and our contemporary culture is that the sacred culture holds up its heroes, saying, “These are the people worth imitating.” The Franciscans in California, for instance, named their missions (and eventually the cities) Santa Barbara, San Francisco, San Jose, Santa Rosa, San Diego.

But what heroes do we offer our children? Arnold Schwarzenegger, Madonna, Sylvester Stallone and Michael Jackson have little or nothing to teach the soul. The frightening thing about that is that we become what we imitate. Fortunately, Catholics have an alternate set of heroes and heroines.


6. Catholics always have something to celebrate.

Guardian angels in October, the communion of saints in November, Our Lady of Guadalupe, Saint Nicholas and Santa Lucia in Advent, Catholic Education Week in January, Mardi Gras, “burying the Alleluia” on Ash Wednesday and resurrecting it on Easter, Pentecost and the Marian feasts—the list seems infinite. I even heard about a Hispanic parish with an Irish pastor where they had a fiesta for Saint Patrick’s Day!

Garrison Keillor, popular author and radio performer, remembers his Lutheran upbringing in his book Lake Wobegon Days. As a boy he envied “Catholic Christmas, Easter, the living rosary and the blessing of the animals, all magnificent. The feast day of Saint Francis was a feast for the eyes. Cows, horses, some pigs, right on the church lawn....The band of third-graders playing Catholic dirges and the great calm of the Sisters, and the flags and the Knights of Columbus decked out in their handsome black suits—I stared at it until my eyes almost fell out....We didn’t go in for feasts or ceremonies...while not far away the Catholics were whooping it up. I wasn’t allowed inside Our Lady, of course, but if the blessing of the animals on the Feast of Saint Francis was any indication, Lord, I didn’t know but what they had elephants in there and acrobats.”

In contrast, my husband teaches Jehovah’s Witness children, who are not allowed to celebrate Halloween, Christmas or even their own birthdays. What a dreary, gray existence it could be without a feast or fast to liven it up!


7. We draw on a rich spirituality.

I know of no other tradition that celebrates the sacredness of the ordinary as we do. All our sacraments name and claim the divine depth that sustains ordinary life. So our symbols that speak most eloquently are drawn from the most usual, earthy things: wheat and vine, water, oil, touch. Such a sacramental theology says that even when we are not aware of it, a wondrous grace and mystery surround us always. Just as the bread and wine are transformed, so are we. The words “This is my body” are spoken not only over bread, but also over us.

A Church that puts Eucharist at its center rewards the seeker, the hungry, those who don’t have their acts together, who don’t know all the answers, but who need to come back, week after week, and are always invited to return to the table. Author Nathan Mitchell reminds us, “We are most ourselves when we gather not for ritual slaughter or strategic planning, but to give thanks.” Our ritual actions prompt us to pay attention to what is already going on—how much God’s grace and power are already at play in our world.


8. We take staunch stands on peace and justice.

Each locale boasts its own examples, but across the United States homeless shelters, hospices, soup kitchens, battered-women’s shelters, AIDS treatment centers, literacy programs, day-care centers, hospitals and schools are sponsored and staffed by the Catholic Church. In many parts of the country we sponsor immigration services and tutoring in English. Internationally the work for justice continues through agencies like Catholic Relief Services, Maryknoll and Jesuit Refugee Services.

When the government proposed welfare cuts that would endanger the poor, the Catholic bishops protested loudly and forthrightly.

These clear actions and positions are balanced by the humility to admit we can’t do it all. As the prayer of Archbishop Oscar Romero said, our limitations are an opportunity for the Lord’s grace to enter and complete our work.


9. The Church can contain tensions.

This may seem odd, but I relish an image of Church like a huge tent or umbrella under which everyone can fit. Sometimes we seem to be splitting our seams, but we all still stay because this is where we belong; this is home. It is a tension into which we can relax, a struggle that can be lived.

Somehow the Catholic Church holds it all in balance: the treasures of the Vatican art galleries and the poverty of the Franciscans; the exuberance of the charismatics and the quietness of centering prayer; drums, guitars, trombones—and Gregorian chant. Any other Church would have a million splinter groups: We contain it all. As James Joyce says, the Catholic Church means “Here comes everybody.” Sister Jose Hobday says her dad joined the Catholic Church because it had more riffraff than any other.


10. It’s your turn!

Now what’s your favorite reason (or reasons) for being a Catholic?
Kathy Coffey is the author of  Hidden Women of the Gospels, Experiencing God With Your Children (both from Crossroad Publishing Company) and poetry published in Saint Anthony Messenger. She first presented these ideas as a keynote address in Lubbock, Texas.


© Copyright St. Anthony Messenger Press. This article was published with the permission of St. Anthony Messenger magazine, which provides study guides to accompany many of its articles. You can access these guides by going to the magazine's Links for Learners page. Teachers will find a wealth of other resources at the St. Anthony Messenger Press web site by clicking on this link:

Published October 1, 1997.